Pierre Chadefaux
Law
Please tell us about your research project.
I am a third-year PhD candidate in public law at Paris-Panthéon-Assas University. My research starts with a simple question: what makes a good environmental law? This question is particularly interesting today, as environmental law is undergoing a major transformation. Traditionally, it sought to protect nature by prohibiting harmful activities and regulating human behaviour. Today, it increasingly sets numerical targets, from reducing greenhouse gas emissions to restoring biodiversity. Environmental law is becoming something like a long list of numbers.
I call this transformation the consequentialist turn in environmental law. But does focusing on results make environmental laws better? And what happens to law when its success is increasingly measured by numbers? My thesis explores how this shift is changing the way environmental laws are made, justified and evaluated, particularly through the growing influence of economic models and scientific expertise.
Could you please tell us a bit more about your scholarship/exchange programme?
I am spending Michaelmas term at Oxford as a visiting scholar at the Institute of European and Comparative Law, while staying at the Maison Française d’Oxford. Beyond the opportunity to meet environmental law scholars and work in Oxford’s remarkable libraries, this visit has been a chance to discover a different way of thinking about law. The openness to other disciplines, the freedom of academic discussion and the importance given to theoretical questions have been particularly enriching for research that brings together law, economics and philosophy.
First impressions of Oxford/the University?
My first surprise was the weather. I arrived expecting endless English rain, but my umbrella has spent most of its time resting comfortably in my room. Oxford itself is extraordinary: a medieval city surrounded by nature, with enormous parks, ancient trees and beautiful countryside just a short walk away. What also struck me was how deeply rooted academic traditions are. From the colleges and their formal dinners to the centuries-old libraries, the past seems to be everywhere. Yet behind all these traditions, I have found a remarkably open and welcoming academic environment, where professors are approachable and discussions are lively.